[pct-l] RE: GG VaporTrail vs ULA P1

[m_factor at hotmail.com (Mara Factor)]

Hi Ann,

Just wanted to make sure you knew about the P-1 reviews at 
http://www.BackpackGearTest.org .  I was one of the testers and really liked 
the pack.  But, I also found that I couldn't carry enough weight in the pack 
to consider using the pack for a PCT thruhike.  I needed something with a 
bit more support and when asked, I usually recommend people check out the 
P-2.

But, I suspect my own personal limitations came into play and someone with a 
stronger upper body might not feel the same way I do about the pack.  If I 
recall correctly, the P-1 was built by Brian precisely for  PCT thruhike.

>From what I remember, most people are pretty comfortable with the pack up to 
25 pounds and can carry more if necessary.  For me, I ws only comfortable up 
to 20 pounds and could carry perhaps up to 25 if necessary.

Needless to say, while I still love having the pack for shorter trips or 
trips where I know I won't have to carry significant water weight, I didn't 
use it on the PCT.

Best of luck with your decision - and your hike,
Mara

P.S.  I used a Kelty Vapor (aka Cloud) and had no problems with it save the 
slipping straps that seem enherent to gros grain ribbon.  If you can find a 
used one or a Kelty Flight, that might be a good option, too.  I would NOT 
pay full price for one of the Kelty Spectra packs.  -MF

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Visit my Travels and Trails web site at:

http://friends.backcountry.net/m_factor
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~



>From: "Aloha! Ann" <AlohaAnn@adelphia.net>
>Date: Thu, 3 Feb 2005 23:39:38 -0500
>
>...Now I'd like to hear all the pros and cons for the ULA P1.  Any one have 
>it?  Use it?  Like it?  Hate it?  Etc., etc. ...