[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: [at-l] Re: Cold giardia and Iodine
Your getting a bit confused. 1) Viruses don't metabolize, they
2) Iodine works as a bleaching agent. It oxidizes/burns the buggers. The
problem with cold water is not the rate of metabolism, but the rate of
oxidation. It simply is slower at a colder temperature.
3) Purifiers make very little sense in US, in any case. The idea of a
purifier is to treat warmer (usually tap) water from questionable
sources overseas. The folks who use purifiers rather than filters simply
have a belt and suspenders and duct tape mentality.
Gary Buffington wrote:
> Iodine kills giardia and other micro-organisms by interfering with their
> cellular metabolism. The organism takes on the temperature of the water.
> Cold microbes have slowed metabolism; therefore, the metabolic time (we
> call it contact time) must be longer according to the tables previously
> published in this list.
> Using this concept, it becomes difficult to understand the logic of a
> "purifier" which contains iodine resin that imparts iodine to the water to
* From the Appalachian Trail Mailing List | http://www.backcountry.net *