[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
[at-l] Treating and Preventing Venomous Bites
- Subject: [at-l] Treating and Preventing Venomous Bites
- From: WHHAWKINS@aol.com
- Date: Thu, 8 Jun 2000 14:46:31 EDT
This is for the FDA.
Wildbill
For Goodness Snakes!
Treating and Preventing Venomous Bites
by John Henkel
They fascinate. They repel.
Some pose a danger. Others are harmless.
And whether they are seen as slimy creatures or colorful curiosities, snakes
play important environmental roles in the fragile ecosystems of the nation's
wildlife areas.
People who frequent these wilderness spots, as well as those who camp, hike,
picnic, or live in snake-inhabited areas, should be aware of potential
dangers posed by venomous snakes. Every state but Maine, Alaska and Hawaii is
home to at least one of 20 domestic poisonous snake species. A bite from one
of these, in which the snake may inject varying degrees of toxic venom,
should always be considered a medical emergency, says the American Red Cross.
About 8,000 people a year receive venomous bites in the United States; nine
to 15 victims die. Some experts say that because victims can't always
positively identify a snake, they should seek prompt care for any bite,
though they may think the snake is nonpoisonous. Even a bite from a so-called
"harmless" snake can cause an infection or allergic reaction in some people.
Medical professionals sometimes disagree about the best way to manage
poisonous snakebites. Some physicians hold off on immediate treatment, opting
for observation of the patient to gauge a bite's seriousness. Procedures such
as fasciotomy, a surgical treatment of tissue around the bite, have some
supporters. But most often, doctors turn to the antidote to snake
venom--antivenin--as a reliable treatment for serious snakebites.
Antivenin is derived from antibodies created in a horse's blood serum when
the animal is injected with snake venom. In humans, antivenin is administered
either through the veins or injected into muscle and works by neutralizing
snake venom that has entered the body. Because antivenin is obtained from
horses, snakebite victims sensitive to horse products must be carefully
managed. The danger is that they could develop an adverse reaction or even a
potentially fatal allergic condition called anaphylactic shock.
The Food and Drug Administration regulates antivenins as part of its
oversight of biological products. The agency requires certain criteria to be
met before these materials are sold, including standards for purification,
packaging and potency. FDA also regulates antivenin labeling, ensuring that
data on potential side effects and other pertinent information are available.
The agency also periodically inspects antivenin production facilities to
ensure compliance with regulations.
Types of Poisonous Snakes
Two families of venomous snakes are native to the United States. The vast
majority are pit vipers, of the family Crotalidae, which include
rattlesnakes, copperheads and cottonmouths (water moccasins). Pit vipers get
their common name from a small "pit" between the eye and nostril that allows
the snake to sense prey at night. They deliver venom through two fangs the
snake can retract at rest but can spring into biting
position rapidly. About 99 percent of the venomous bites in this country are
from pit vipers. Some--Mojave rattlesnakes or canebrake rattlesnakes, for
example--carry a neurotoxic venom that can affect the brain or spinal cord.
Copperheads, on the other hand, have a milder and less dangerous venom that
sometimes may not require antivenin treatment.
The other family of domestic poisonous snakes is Elapidae, which
includes two species of coral snakes found chiefly in the Southern
states. Related to the much more dangerous Asian cobras and kraits, coral
snakes have small mouths and short teeth, which give them a less efficient
venom delivery than pit vipers. People bitten by coral snakes lack the
characteristic fang marks of pit vipers, sometimes making the bite hard to
detect.
Though coral snakebites are rare in the United States--only about 25 a year
by some estimates--the snake's neurotoxic venom can be dangerous. A 1987
study in the Journal of the American Medical Association examined 39 victims
of coral snakebites. There were no deaths, but several victims experienced
respiratory paralysis, one of the hazards of neurotoxic venom.
Some nonpoisonous snakes, such as the scarlet king snake, mimic the bright
red, yellow and black coloration of the coral snake. This potential for
confusion underscores the importance of seeking care for any snakebite
(unless positive identification of a nonpoisonous snake can be made).
The bites of both pit vipers and coral snakes can be effectively treated with
antivenin. But other factors, such as time elapsed since being bitten and
care taken before arriving at the hospital, also are critical.
First Aid for Snakebites
Over the years, snakebite victims have been exposed to all kinds of slicing,
freezing and squeezing as stopgap measures before receiving medical care.
Some of these approaches, like cutting into a bite and attempting to suck out
the venom, have largely fallen out of favor.
"In the past five or 10 years, there's been a backing off in first aid from
really invasive things like making incisions," says Arizona physician David
Hardy, M.D., who studies snakebite epidemiology. "This is because we now know
these things can do harm and we don't know if they really change the outcome."
Many health-care professionals embrace just a few basic first-aid techniques.
According to the American Red Cross, these steps should be taken:
•Wash the bite with soap and water.
•Immobilize the bitten area and keep it lower than the heart.
•Get medical help.
"The main thing is to get to a hospital and don't delay," says Hardy.
"Most bites don't occur in real isolated situations, so it is feasible to get
prompt [medical care]." He describes cases in Arizona where people have
caught rattlesnakes for sport and gotten bitten. "They waited until they
couldn't stand the pain anymore and finally went to the hospital after the
venom had been in there a few hours. But by then, they'd lost an opportunity
for [effective treatment]," which increased the odds of long-term
complications. Some medical professionals, along with the American Red Cross,
cautiously recommend two other measures:
•If a victim is unable to reach medical care within 30 minutes, a bandage,
wrapped two to four inches above the bite, may help slow venom. The bandage
should not cut off blood flow from a vein or artery. A good rule of thumb is
to make the band loose enough that a finger can slip
under it.
•A suction device may be placed over the bite to help draw
venom out of the wound without making cuts. Suction instruments often are
included in commercial snakebite kits.
Treatment Drawbacks
Antivenins have been in use for decades and are the only effective
treatment for some bites. "Antivenins have a fairly good safety record," says
Don Tankersley, deputy director of FDA's division of hematology. "There are
sometimes reactions to them, even life-threatening reactions, but then you're
treating a life-threatening situation. It's clearly a case of weighing the
risks versus the benefits."
People previously treated with antivenin for snakebites probably will develop
a lifelong sensitivity to horse products. To identify these and other
sensitive patients, hospitals typically obtain a record of the victim's
experience with snakebites or horse products. But some people with no history
of such exposures may have become sensitive through contact with horses, or
possibly exposure to horse dander, and not know they are sensitive. Others
may be sensitive without any known or remembered contact with horses. So
hospitals also perform a skin test that quickly shows any sensitivity. Some
hypersensitive patients may even react severely to the small amount of
antivenin used in the skin test. Hospitals have procedures for reviving
patients with serious reactions. Some victims with positive skin tests can be
desensitized by gradually administering small amounts of antivenin.
Newer kinds of antivenins derived from sheep are under study now and show
some promise, according to FDA officials. But progress has been slow due to
low demand and the small number of venomous bites a year.
Certain venomous snakebites may be treated without using antivenin. This is
usually a judgment call the doctor makes based on the snake's size and other
factors, which normally involves close monitoring of patients in a medical
facility.
"In some areas, such as desert areas, most rattlesnakes are small and don't
have as potent a venom," says Edward L. Hall, M.D., a Thomasville, Ga.,
trauma surgeon who treats snakebites. "You might get by with those patients
in not using antivenin." But with other snakes, Hall says,
antivenin can be a lifesaver. For example, the Eastern diamondback
rattlesnake--found in large quantities in the region of Georgia where Hall
practices medicine and in other Southern states from the Carolinas to
Louisiana--can reach six feet in length and deliver a potent payload
of venom. "It's an enormously dangerous bite that requires very aggressive
treatment [with antivenin] or the patient will die," Hall says.
Treatment Dilemmas
Because not all snakebites, including those from the same species, are
equally dangerous, doctors sometimes face a dilemma over whether or not to
administer antivenin. Venomous snakes, even dangerous ones like the Eastern
diamondback, don't always release venom when they bite. Other
snakes may release too small an amount to pose a hazard.
Hall says his experience in Georgia bears this out. "Some 20 to 30 percent of
patients we see who have been bitten by a snake, who actually have fang
marks, have not received any venom at all." He says one reason
for this may be poor timing by the snake. "Pit vipers have a very
sophisticated mechanism that allows them to deliver venom at the exact
instant the teeth are sunk into the flesh. So it has to be precise
timing. But what we often see is that the [snake's timing is off and]
venom is squirted on the pants leg or released prematurely."
Another complicating factor is the diverse potency of venom. "Venom can
vary within species and even within litter mates--brothers and sisters,"
says Arizona physician Hardy. For example, he says, a common pit viper
in the Southwest, the Mojave rattlesnake, may carry a powerful
neurotoxic venom in some areas and a less toxic one in others.
Hall's work in Georgia and Florida shows that factors such as genetic
differences among snakes, their age, nutritional status, and the time of
year also can affect venom potency. All these variables make it nearly
impossible for doctors to characterize a "typical" venomous snakebite.
That's why there exists what Hall calls "so much controversy" about
snakebite treatment.
The solution, Hall says, lies with the patient. "Truly the only way to
look at snakebites is on an individual basis and on the patient's actual
reaction to the venom." Basic signs like pain, swelling and bleeding,
along with more complicated reactions such as ecchymosis (purple
discoloration), necrosis (tissue dies and turns black), low blood
pressure, and tingling of lips and tongue give medical professionals
clues to the individual basis and on the patient's actual reaction to
the ven
Some experts emphasize that though antivenin can effectively reverse the
effects of venom and save life and limb, there is no guarantee that it
can reverse damage already done, such as necrosis. Some patients may
later require skin grafts or other treatment. Arizona physician Hardy
says the potential for limiting complications is one compelling reason
to seek medical treatment as soon as possible after a snakebite.
Avoiding Snakebites
Some bites, such as those inflicted when snakes are accidentally stepped
on or encountered in wilderness settings, are nearly impossible to
prevent. But experts say a few precautions can lower the risk of being
bitten:
•Leave snakes alone. Many people are bitten because they try to kill a
snake or get a closer look at it. •Stay out of tall grass unless you
wear thick leather boots, and remain on hiking paths as much as
possible. •Keep hands and feet out of areas you can't see. Don't pick up
rocks or firewood unless you are out of a snake's striking distance. (A
snake can strike half its length, Hardy says.) •Be cautious and alert
when climbing rocks.
What do you do if you encounter a snake when hiking or picnicking? Says
Hardy: "Just walk around the snake, giving it a little berth--six feet
is plenty. But leave it alone and don't try to catch it."
Though poisonous snakes can be dangerous, snake venom may have a
positive side. Clinical trials are presently under way to test the
therapeutic value of a venom-derived product called ancrod in treating
stroke. Earlier proposals, using snake venom to treat neuromuscular
disorders such as multiple sclerosis, never reached the clinical trial
stage.
John Henkel is a staff writer for FDA Consumer.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
How NOT to Treat a Snakebite
Though U.S. medical professionals may not agree on every aspect of what
to do for snakebite first aid, they are nearly unanimous in their views
of what not to do. Among their recommendations:
•No ice or any other type of cooling on the bite. Research has shown
this to be potentially harmful. •No tourniquets. This cuts blood flow
completely and may result in loss of the affected limb. •No electric
shock. This method is under study and has yet to be proven effective. It
could harm the victim. •No incisions in the wound. Such measures have
not been proven useful and may cause further injury.
Arizona physician David Hardy, M.D., says part of the problem when
someone is bitten is the element of surprise. "People often aren't
trained in what to do, and they are in a panic situation." He adds that
preparation--which includes knowing in advance how to get to the nearest
hospital--could greatly reduce anxiety and lead to more effective care.
--J.H.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
FDA Consumer magazine (November 1995)
* From the AT-L | Need help? http://www.backcountry.net/faq.html *
==============================================================================